New York is packed with memories and places that shaped the culture, style, and heartbeat of the city. While Part 1 highlighted 15 legendary spots, here’s the next batch of beloved New York places the community wishes could return—each with its own story, vibe, and legacy.

1. Dublin House

A classic Irish pub known for its lively atmosphere and loyal patrons, a true New York watering hole.(Reopened as of 2026)

2. Theater 80 Saint Marks

An offbeat theater venue and bar on the Lower East Side, a hub for performance art and underground culture.

3. Dumas Patisserie

A beloved neighborhood bakery known for its authentic pastries and warm, inviting vibe.

4. City Bakery

Famous for its innovative baked goods and cozy space, this was a staple for locals and visitors alike.

5. Terrace in the Sky

A rooftop lounge that offered stunning skyline views and a chill atmosphere high above the city streets.

6. McHale’s

An old-school Irish pub that was part of the city’s rich tradition of neighborhood bars. (Open as of 2026)

7. Neary’s

Another classic pub with strong roots in New York’s Irish-American community, famous for its friendly crowds.

8. Reminiscence

A vintage-inspired cocktail lounge that felt like stepping back into a different era.

9. Shakespeare’s on MacDougal

A Greenwich Village spot beloved for its bohemian atmosphere and as a hangout for artists and writers.

10. Gem Spa

Iconic for its egg creams and as a cultural landmark in the East Village.

11. Max’s Kansas City

A legendary nightclub and restaurant that was a nexus for musicians, artists, and the downtown scene.

12. North Star Pub

Known for its cozy vibe and welcoming community feel, a favorite neighborhood bar.

13. Paddy Reilly’s

An Irish pub famous for its lively music sessions and authentic atmosphere. (Open as of 2026)

14. ZumZum

A Middle Eastern spot that was well-loved for its flavorful food and vibrant setting.

15. CHARAS / El Bohio

A community-driven cultural center and nightclub that was an important space for arts and activism.

16. The John Houseman

An elegant, classic bar named after the famed actor, known for its cocktails and old-school charm.

17. The Blue Mill Tavern (original)

A historic tavern remembered for its character and role in the city’s social scene.

18. The Botton Line

A renowned music venue that hosted countless legendary acts over the years.

19. Dojos

A nightlife spot known for its eclectic crowd and underground appeal.

20. Roseland Ballroom

A famed dance hall and concert venue, iconic for its grand scale and cultural significance.

The City’s Spirit Lives in These Places

Each of these spots carried a unique slice of New York’s spirit—whether through music, food, culture, or community. Though many have faded from the cityscape, their memories live on in the hearts of those who experienced them.

Recommended for you:

Shop the latest brands featured on People Globally Shop here:

Click here to Shop